Since making lists and judging things are practically my two favorite things . . . why not keep a running list of my personal ranking of the new fall shows? I'll add to it as I watch things, and adjust if my feelings changed based on later episodes. (If I watch later episodes.) Note: This is how much I LIKE things, not just an evaluation of quality - there are certainly shows that I think are reasonably effective at doing what they're trying to do, but what they're trying to do is not something I enjoy. And we obviously all have all sorts of conscious and unconscious biases, but I've tried to ignore truly external factors, like "That actor was a jerk to me once" or "They cast my friend."